I'll start with a couple of records for someone looking for something more than a big collection of the most familiar carols. The first is Christmas at St John's, with St John's College Choir in Cambridge. This is structured like a service, with carols and motets separated by antiphons (chant) and it works really well. The music traces a narrative from Advent (O come, O come, Emmanuel) through to Christmas (finishing with O Come, all ye faithful and the antiphon Hodie Christus natus est), which is also effective. There are a few of the carols we all learnt as children as well as more modern classics like Howells' A Spotless Rose, Warlock's Bethlehem Down, and some brilliant, even more recent pieces like Judith Bingham's powerful The clouded Heaven and Morten Lauridsen's sublime setting of O magnum mysterium.This has become one of my favourite Christmas records in a very short space of time and it's well worth exploring.
CD Choice: MDT
Download choice: Hyperion Records
Next is a CD that's a real change in scale from the massed voices of the John's choir. Just four male singers, augmented by three female voices for some of the music, creating a warm, intimate sound based on medieval texts and carols. I Sing The Birth by New York Polyphony is a wonderful record. There are two settings of the text of the 'Coventry Carol', Lullay lulla..., the setting from the medieval mystery play and the twentieth century version by Kenneth Leighton. Away in a manger is sung to a traditional northern French tune, which works really well. And with the older music there are more contemporary pieces, like Andrew Smith's settings of Veni Redemptor gentium (commissioned for this recording) and his Nunc dimittis, and Peter Maxwell Davies' haunting The Fader of Heaven.There's a great deal of thought gone into the sequencing of the music in this programme and the combinations of successive sections of plainchant, polyphony, medieval carols and plainchant once more, interspersed with the modern music, makes this a really rewarding journey. And hopefully one you'll want to repeat many times.
CD Choice: MDT
Download choice: Amazon Downloads
Back to the English choral tradition and back to the more familiar, here is the choir of the Roman Catholic Westminster Cathedral in another brilliant Christmas CD from Hyperion Records. Adeste fideles is a great compilation of some of our best-loved carols. Beginning with O come, all ye faithful and ending with Hark! the herald angels sing, it's a really well performed selection of many of the carols we've known all our lives. So we have, Once in royal David's city, O little town of Bethlehem, Harold Darke's arrangement of In the bleak mid-winter, Away in a manger, The holly and the ivy, and Silent night.You would probably describe all of the music on here as classic, timeless Christmas music. But there are some which are probably less widely known, like Patrick Hadley's joyful I sing of a maiden (with a sixteenth-century text), Herbert Howells' lilting Sing lullaby and John Tavener's minimalist and striking The Lamb. If you don't know Bethlehem Down, then you really should, because Peter Warlock's carol is a very beautiful thing, and the arrangements by Andrew Carter (folk carol I wonder as I wander and the French tune to, and the textual adaptation of, Bede's A maiden most gentle) are really effective. It's a lovely CD, this one, performed with great warmth, a full sound and with some super singing.
CD Choice: Europadisc
Download choice: Hyperion Records
The CD to get if you want pretty much all the carols you knew as a child is the next, and last, one. One of the finest non-ecclesiastical English choirs for a number of years now has been The Sixteen, under their music director Harry Christophers. They've released what consists of a real treasure trove of Christmas music, whether that's big oratorios like Bach's Christmas Oratorio and Handel's Messiah (twice: once with Ton Koopman, and more recently on their own), Britten's Ceremony of Carols, medieval English Christmas music, and this one, A Traditional Christmas Carol Collection.I'd say this was pretty much your best bet if you want to get pretty much all of the really popular carols, sung beautifully and with great sound. Sometimes carol collections can come across as being a bit overblown or sentimental. Here the relatively small size of the choir gives each of the carols a transparency and lightness that stops them cloying. One to put on in the evening on Christmas Eve with some mince pies and mulled wine. Follow this link to see the tracklist (and to hear some snippets), which will save me listing them all! It's the only one of the CDs on this page which includes my favourite when I was little, God rest you merry, Gentlemen.
CD Choice: Europadisc (single CD). Or, as part of The Sixteen's Christmas Collection (3 CDs), Europadisc.
Download choice: The Classical Shop








Sunday may have been the start of Advent in the church year, but 1 December is the day when calendars and candles are pressed into service in the countdown to the big feast. The boys woke up this morning to find that the elves had been in the night (presumably welcomed by